> For the complete documentation index, see [llms.txt](https://docs.eu-pactum.com/llms.txt). Markdown versions of documentation pages are available by appending `.md` to page URLs; this page is available as [Markdown](https://docs.eu-pactum.com/price-lists/claims/push-back-on-a-claim.md).

# Push back on a claim

{% hint style="info" %}
**Early access.** This feature is available to all Price Lists customers as early access. It may change as we improve it — tell your Pactum contact what works and what doesn't.
{% endhint %}

Turn a claim's verdict into a reply to the supplier, then record how the claim ended.

## Draft a pushback email

1. In the Assistant conversation where you submitted the claim, ask for a reply, for example "Draft a pushback email". Say how you want to respond if you have a position: "Accept 3% and ask to delay it to Q2".
2. The Assistant shows an **Email draft** with **To**, **Subject** and **Body**. Edit any of them in place.
3. Click **Send email**. It opens the draft in your own email client. Nothing is sent until you send it from there.

The draft answers the supplier's own reasons, states your own facts (such as the price you pay today), asks for a cost breakdown where the increase couldn't be verified, and proposes alternatives. It never accepts more than you told the Assistant to accept.

<figure><img src="https://2769938103-files.gitbook.io/~/files/v0/b/gitbook-x-prod.appspot.com/o/spaces%2F1FM7KTpbu7nDWmneLhlf%2Fuploads%2FyQlB83zoIUTHipOXx8NO%2Fimage.png?alt=media&amp;token=83e78280-627e-44b3-bc19-c434969ae11f" alt=""><figcaption></figcaption></figure>

## How to read it

| Draft                 | What it says about your analysis                                                                                                                                     |
| --------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| Guarded (the default) | Your cost drivers only in general terms, such as "base metals have been flat over this period", and no counter figure of its own.                                    |
| Specific              | Also how much each cost category moved and the increase your data supports, and it counters at that figure. Ask for it with "add the numbers" or "be more specific". |

Neither draft names the indices or their weights. The Assistant can be fully specific in chat; only the email draft is written to be shared with the supplier.

## Conclude the claim

On the claim page, click **Conclude** and choose **Success**, **Failed**, **Closed** or **Abandoned**. To conclude several, select them on the **Claims** page and use **Change resolution**. A concluded claim can be reopened with **Reopen claim**.

Use **Notes** and **Edit tags** to keep track, and filter the Claims list by **Recommendation**, **Status**, **Effective** (**Within 30 days**) or **Tags**.

## From claim to negotiation

You can't start a Price Lists negotiation from a claim yet. To negotiate the same materials with an AI-led negotiation, create the negotiation from the material's opportunity or from the supplier in Portfolio. If a negotiation is already linked to a claim, the claim shows **View negotiation**.

## Good to know

* **Two-week auto-close.** A claim you haven't concluded is closed automatically two weeks after you submit it, with status **Closed**. No warning is sent first.
* **Who can do what.** Everyone in the workspace sees all claims on the Claims page, with notes and tags. Only the person who submitted a claim can conclude, reopen or update it. Assistant conversations are private.
* **View-only users** see **Conclude**, **Change resolution** and **Edit tags** disabled.
* **Effective** is the supplier's effective date, not the auto-close date.

## Ask the Assistant

* "Draft a pushback email to Acme Components for this claim."
* "Make it more specific and counter at the increase our data supports."
* "Does Acme Components have any open claims?"

## Related

* [Read the verdict](https://docs.eu-pactum.com/price-lists/claims/read-the-verdict.md)
* [Submit a claim](https://docs.eu-pactum.com/price-lists/claims/submit-a-claim.md)
* [Act on an opportunity](https://docs.eu-pactum.com/price-lists/opportunities/act-on-an-opportunity.md)
* [Negotiation statuses](https://docs.eu-pactum.com/price-lists/reference/negotiation-statuses.md)
* [Glossary](https://docs.eu-pactum.com/price-lists/reference/glossary.md)
