> For the complete documentation index, see [llms.txt](https://docs.eu-pactum.com/llms.txt). Markdown versions of documentation pages are available by appending `.md` to page URLs; this page is available as [Markdown](https://docs.eu-pactum.com/price-lists/claims/read-the-verdict.md).

# Read the verdict

{% hint style="info" %}
**Early access.** This feature is available to all Price Lists customers as early access. It may change as we improve it — tell your Pactum contact what works and what doesn't.
{% endhint %}

Understand what Price Lists concluded about a supplier's price increase, how sure it is, and what it suggests you do.

## What you see

Open a claim from **Claims**, or click **Open full analysis** under the result in the Assistant. From top to bottom:

* **The verdict header.** The claim verdict, the overpay risk, and one sentence comparing the ask with the market. A bar shows the market move in green and the part of the ask above it hatched.
* **Evidence covers**, **Window** and **Indices**: how much of the cost base is backed by index data, the period measured, and how many indices were used.
* **The case**: the strongest points, most important first, split into **Where it holds** and **Where to push** for a partial verdict.
* **Market movement vs. the ask**: each cost driver's move over the window.
* **By material — suggested counter (opening position)**: **Asked**, **Counter to** and **Avoid** per unit, under totals such as **Current annual spend** and **Annual exposure**.
* **Indices we matched to the drivers they named**, and the supplier's documents.

<figure><img src="https://2769938103-files.gitbook.io/~/files/v0/b/gitbook-x-prod.appspot.com/o/spaces%2F1FM7KTpbu7nDWmneLhlf%2Fuploads%2Fzds4HXsNUA72fuOWrFU6%2Fimage.png?alt=media&amp;token=2189ac83-81e8-4035-87c9-ccf01b1f92ff" alt=""><figcaption></figcaption></figure>

## How to read it

| Verdict             | Meaning                                                                     | Recommendation |
| ------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------- |
| Justified           | Market movement supports the full ask, and the independent estimate agrees. | Accept         |
| Partially justified | Part of the ask holds, or the evidence is too thin to say more.             | Negotiate      |
| Overstated          | The market moved, but much less than the ask.                               | Negotiate      |
| Unsupported         | Market data doesn't back the increase.                                      | Reject         |

**How the market figure is found.** Price Lists works out what each material is made of (such as steel, energy or labour), links each part to a market index, and weights each index's move by its share of the cost. It checks the drivers the supplier named and makes its own independent estimate. The window is the claim's dates; without them, the 12 months before the effective date (**assumed 12-month · indicative**). Open a matched index to see it in the [Index Catalogue](https://docs.eu-pactum.com/price-lists/index-catalogue/browse-and-compare-indices.md).

**Coverage matters.** If the indices cover less than half of the cost base, Price Lists won't call a claim Overstated or Unsupported. The header then says there isn't enough priced to judge, and the risk shows **Overpay risk unknown**.

**Overpay risk** is **Low**, **Medium** or **High**, by how much of the claim is Overstated or Unsupported. A claim that is mostly unverifiable is never Low.

**Estimates.** A claim without a figure shows **Estimate** and a range ("The market supports between +3% and +5%") with a confidence level. Treat it as a ceiling: anything above it needs a cost breakdown from the supplier. With too little coverage, no range is shown.

<figure><img src="https://2769938103-files.gitbook.io/~/files/v0/b/gitbook-x-prod.appspot.com/o/spaces%2F1FM7KTpbu7nDWmneLhlf%2Fuploads%2FoX8NkAXql2gIT37Rv5WI%2Fimage.png?alt=media&amp;token=51be1bc1-13b4-44a2-8a1a-be6026268df2" alt=""><figcaption></figcaption></figure>

## Good to know

* **Chat and claim page agree.** The result card in the Assistant and the claim page show the same analysis. A figure the Assistant gives in a general answer, outside a claim, is a different calculation, such as a commodity's 12-month trend or cost movement since your last purchase, so it can differ. For a supplier's ask, use the claim result.
* **Currency.** Unit prices show in the claim's currency. Spend and exposure show in your workspace's default currency.
* **Correct it in chat.** In the conversation where you submitted the claim, correct the percentage, dates, justification, supplier or window, or add context, and the analysis re-runs. Line items can't be corrected; submit a corrected document.

## Ask the Assistant

* "Why is this claim only partially justified?"
* "The increase is 8%, not 18%."
* "Re-evaluate from January 2025 until today."

## Related

* [Submit a claim](https://docs.eu-pactum.com/price-lists/claims/submit-a-claim.md)
* [Push back on a claim](https://docs.eu-pactum.com/price-lists/claims/push-back-on-a-claim.md)
* [Find and compare indices](https://docs.eu-pactum.com/price-lists/index-catalogue/browse-and-compare-indices.md)
* [Glossary](https://docs.eu-pactum.com/price-lists/reference/glossary.md)
